In a startling development that has gripped New York City, Sheldon Johnson, a 48-year-old former convict turned criminal justice activist, has been charged with murder following the discovery of a dismembered body in a Bronx apartment. This case has sent shockwaves through communities, highlighting a tragic arc from redemption to alleged criminal relapse.
Johnson, previously known for his work with the Queens Defenders office and his advocacy for criminal justice reform, was arrested on Thursday, March 7, 2024, after police found the gruesome remains of 44-year-old Collin Small. The discovery included a human torso in a blue bin and a head in a freezer in the apartment, alongside other body parts, sparking a citywide discussion on rehabilitation and trust.
Sheldon Johnson’s journey from a life of crime to an advocate for justice was well-documented, including an appearance on Joe Rogan’s podcast where he discussed his transformation and work with troubled youth. Having spent 25 years in prison for attempted murder as a member of the Bloods gang, Johnson had publicly claimed to have turned his life around after his release, working to support those navigating the criminal justice system.
However, the recent charges paint a starkly different picture. Surveillance footage from the scene showed Johnson carrying cleaning supplies and a garbage bag into the apartment, actions that led to his arrest and subsequent charges of murder, manslaughter, and weapon possession.
Eyewitness accounts and police reports suggest that the victim, Collin Small, may have had a previous dispute with Johnson dating back to their time together in Sing Sing prison. Neighbors reported hearing distressing pleas from Small before gunshots rang out, a chilling detail that adds a somber note to the investigation.
“I have a family!” were the desperate words heard by neighbors, underscoring the human tragedy at the heart of this case. Upon noticing Johnson’s unusual behavior, the building’s superintendent expressed concern, including his late-night visits and disguise attempts, which ultimately contributed to the police investigation.
The implications of this case extend beyond the immediate tragedy, touching on the broader themes of redemption, trust, and the challenges facing individuals attempting to reintegrate into society after incarceration. Johnson, who had been seen as a success story of rehabilitation, now faces the possibility of returning to prison, a devastating blow to his narrative of change and the communities he aimed to serve.
The investigation into Collin Small’s death continues, with the motive and full circumstances still under examination. Police and the Queens Defender’s office have yet to make further comments as the legal process unfolds.