Recent statements by former Defense Secretary Mark Esper about potential military deployment against U.S. citizens have ignited fresh debate over executive power limits, while drawing strong reactions from media figures and presidential candidates.
Esper, who served as Defense Secretary under former President Donald Trump, expressed serious concerns about Trump’s suggestions regarding military use against civilians. “I take these comments seriously because I lived it in 2020,” Esper said, referencing attempts to deploy the National Guard against protesters during civil unrest.
The former Pentagon chief’s warnings gained renewed attention after MSNBC host Joy Reid addressed the topic during a recent broadcast. Reid referenced Esper’s previous interactions with Trump, noting that the former Defense Secretary had to explicitly tell Trump, “No, you cannot have the military shoot American citizens.”
These discussions have emerged amid broader concerns about potential military deployment against U.S. citizens. According to retired Major General Randy Manner, if elected, a president could utilize the National Guard “almost in any way that he wants.”
The controversy has extended beyond traditional news coverage into corporate media discussions. Tesla CEO Elon Musk sparked additional debate by inquiring about MSNBC’s price after Donald Trump Jr. suggested the possibility of purchasing the network. However, industry experts note that such an acquisition faces significant obstacles, as MSNBC is not currently for sale.
The network’s parent company, Comcast, plans to spin off its cable channels into a new publicly traded company, a process expected to take approximately one year.
Earlier accounts from Esper’s memoir, “A Sacred Oath,” provide additional context to current discussions. The book, vetted by nearly three dozen 4-star generals, senior civilians, and Cabinet members, details various encounters regarding military deployment considerations.
Trump’s campaign has responded to these discussions through a spokesperson, stating that recent comments about using the National Guard referred specifically to those who “seek to undermine democracy.”
The debate continues to evolve as media coverage expands. Reid’s recent broadcast also included cautionary messages about political divisions affecting personal relationships, particularly during holiday gatherings.
Industry analysts note that while speculation about MSNBC’s ownership continues, any immediate divestment would face significant tax implications that could prevent a sale.